Langton Capital – 2025-10-06 – PREMIUM – JDW, BrewDog, Cote, trading, energy costs, surveys, holidays & other:
JDW, BrewDog, Cote, trading, energy costs, surveys, holidays & other:PREMIUM EMAIL – PLEASE DO NOT FORWARD: A DAY IN THE LIFE: Our toaster blew up the other day. Well, it didn’t blow up, it simply stopped working and it wasn’t the other day, it was back in the summer and it was, after all, maybe twenty years old. And it had seen a lot of action when the kids were at home so it didn’t really owe us anything but, whatever the ups and downs, it left us without a toaster and, when you feel the need for a Marmite toasty, that’s not good. Fortunately, or at least we initially thought fortunately, we had still-boxed spare in the cupboard under the stairs that had never been used. True, the box had ‘basics’ stamped across it but needs must. We used it and then inertia set in because this was probably three months ago. And, as it seems able to randomly burn one slice of bread whilst doing nothing to another and even scorch one side but leave the other whiter than when it went in, we really must bin it. But it works and I’m from Yorkshire. I just can’t throw it out. I’ll have to develop a taste for whatever it produces. Anyway, The Mighty Hull managed a win at the weekend, so not all bad. Let’s move on to the news: PUBS & RESTAURANTS: Trading: CGA has updated on trading for the middle-two weeks of September (weeks to 13th and 20th respectively) saying that long drinks remained steady whilst a number of other categories fell in money terms – and by even more so in real terms… • In the week to 13 September, CGA reports that cider, beer and soft drink sales all rose by 1% in monetary terms. It reports, however, that spirits sales were down by 7.1% and wine sales were 8.5% lower than they were a year ago. Drink sales as a whole were down by 1.4%. • CGA goes on to report that sales in the week to 20th September were down by 3% overall. All categories were down but longer drinks beer, soft drinks and cider were down by ‘only’ 1%, 1.8% and 4.8% respectively. Spirits sales were down by 6.2% and wine sales were some 7.6% lower. • CGA says the ‘figures represent a slight softening of trading for pubs, bars and suppliers after a solid end to summer.’ Factoring in inflation, and the drops are perhaps a little more material. Nonetheless, CGA maintains that ‘sales had been ahead year-on-year for five weeks out of six between late July and early September.’ • CGA’s Rachel Weller says ‘the key On Premise sales patterns that we saw over summer—of generally flat sales but resilience for LAD [long alcoholic drinks] brands—look like they are extending into the autumn season.’ She says that ‘growth is largely being driven by higher prices rather than increased volumes, and many consumers are clearly still keeping a very close eye on value when they drink out.’ • Ms Weller says ‘the cooler months will hopefully bring better fortunes for the spirits and wine categories, but pubs, bars and suppliers will have to work hard for any year-on-year gains.’ Pricing intentions / inflation: The Bank of England’s poll of finance chiefs has suggested that inflation could well stay above the Bank’s 2% target for some time to come… • Finance bosses expect to raise prices by 3.7% in the next year whilst reducing hiring or actually cutting headcount. The result may dampen hopes of further interest rate cuts in the short term. Energy costs: JD Wetherspoon cautioned on Friday that energy costs would be materially higher than had been forecast. This because some users, via higher standing charges, will be required to fund the subsidies offered to heavy users of energy such as steel producers and other heavy industrial companies…. • The rationale is that the latter need to compete on an international stage, where energy might be sourced cheaper. Companies (and sectors such as leisure) being asked to subsidise the above, however, are crying foul. • Kate Nicholls, chair of UKH, says this ‘is the clearest sign yet that the energy market is broken and enormously frustrating that it is community pubs and neighbourhood restaurants that will bear the brunt once again.’ Other news: VAT in Ireland. VAT on certain hospitality companies in Ireland it to be cut from 13.5% to 9% from July 2026. Hotels will not be included but a number of other business segments, such as franchisee businesses for McDonald’s and other international brands, will be covered by the reduction. Prosecco now reportedly accounts for around a third of all Italian wine sales in the USA. JD WETHERSPOON – FY RESULTS CONFERENCE CALL: Following the release of its FY numbers, JD Wetherspoon hosted a conference call for analysts and out comments thereon are set out below: Headline numbers: • The above table is becoming a little clunky but we’re leaving the pre-Covid numbers in for the moment in order to provide context. Divisional trading: • JDW reports that LFL sales for the group as a whole rose by 5.1%. It splits this as to 5.1% for bar sales, 5.0% for food, 11.0% for slot machines and minus 11.9% for accommodation. • This is as a result of the group removing stock from OTAs (which are expensive). • Q. What did franchised pubs contribute? It’s too early to put a number on it. Most have not been branded for a full year yet. Sales look reasonable. Operating standards have been good. o Q. Opportunities? Co mentions Papa’s. It would like to do 10-15 over time. Haven would like to do more. o Q. Could be 23 by end-FY26. Co is ‘still not pencilling in material revenues’. It will be meaningful from FY27 onwards. More on current trading & outlook: • Wetherspoon reiterates that LFL sales in the first nine weeks of the current financial year were 3.2% higher than the same weeks in FY25. • Costs as a whole remain an issue but energy costs have now been fixed until FY29. The non-commodity element will rise from later this year. o Q. More detail on energy costs? Some can be hedged, much not. Two new levies have been introduced and there have been underlying increases as well. Total for JDW is £7m. The Co had expected an increase of around a quarter of this amount. This comes in from October. It is newish news. o Q. Could you give us a blended figure? £40m from Budget, £7m from energy. Wages & energy are the main areas. The April 2026 NLW has not been announced. Apart from energy & labour, other costs are ‘broadly in line with CPI’. Co is ‘a little below CPI on food & drink’. o Q. Repairs & maintenance. In cash terms, little changed on prior year. It will rise a little this year. Been 5-5.5% of sales in the past – and similar in FY26. • Q. Pricing intentions? Co does not provide detail but ‘will try to keep price rises to a minimum’. Co ‘will try to drive volumes’. • Q. Budget wish list? Would like a cut in VAT on food. Also, business rates reform would be helpful. • Across licensed operators, JDW is now nearly twice as busy as the UK’s number two, which is Nando’s. • Q. The company expects a ‘reasonable outcome’ for FY26, could you put a figure on this? Broker (Investec) has edged back numbers to £86m this year. That ‘seems reasonable’. • Q. Trading has recently slowed. Co is ‘not reading too much into this’. It says comps are tougher in September and ‘underlying trading is steady’. Debt, balance sheet and other: • JDW has now bought back over a third of the shares it issued in the immediate wake of Covid. It has spent around £107m in doing so. o Q. What drives buy-backs? It remains opportunistic. There are no set mechanics. Depends on other opportunities etc. • The company is ‘trading comfortably within its debt limits’. Property portfolio: • The group has opened three pubs since the year-end. It should open around 15 in the year as a whole with around 15 franchised pubs likely to be opened in addition to this. • Q. Outlook? The company will open more units than it closes this year ‘for sure’. Langton comment: • JDW has traded strongly during the year under review. Whilst the operator was helped by the weather over Q2 and Q3 – as was the industry as a whole – LFL sales’ growth has subsequently eased back to 3.2% in the current financial year. • The company’s shares performed strongly in Q2 this year but they have since given ground and a glance at a longer term chart puts the group’s post Covid recovery in perspective. JDW’s shares reached around 1400p in Q2-2021 and, despite the group’s efforts in terms of trading performance, they currently change hands at less than half that price. • JDW has maintained both its value offer and its sales momentum and it will ‘keep price increases to a minimum’. It prefers, where possible, to drive volumes. • Excluding the franchised outlets, which contribute minimally at present but which should become more material over time, JDW is now largely a freehold-based estate. Some 73% of its pubs are freehold (compared with 43% in FY2011). • Whilst the immediate cost outlook is challenging, the hospitality market as a whole should grow more rapidly than GDP over time. COMPANY NEWS: JD Wetherspoon’s shares fell by 37.5p or 5.6% on Friday on the back of the group’s full year numbers and update as to current trading. BrewDog is reported to have sold its Lost Forest. The move came after around half the trees planted died in 2023 as a result of adverse weather. The company reportedly paid £8.8m for the land. The Karali Group has bought restaurant chain Côte Restaurant Group. It had been thought that current private equity owner, Partners Group, was about to inject further funds into the business. • Cote CEO Emma Dinnis says the sale ‘is a huge positive for all involved.’ She adds ‘the sector continues to face challenges, but with the strength of our people and a clear vision, I’m confident we’ll ensure Côte remains everyone’s favourite brasserie. With a delicious new menu amplifying what we do best and exciting plans for the future, we will continue to transform and grow this brand.’ The Karali Group is a family-owned franchise business. EG Group has sold bakery business Cooplands to a group of investors based in Yorkshire. The business was founded in the county in 1885. The terms of the deal were not disclosed. In the US, Paul Brown, co-founder & CEO at Inspire Brands, the company that owns Dunkin Donuts, Arby’s and a number of other F&B brands, has written on Linked In ‘today, we celebrated the opening of Dunkin’s 10,000th U.S. location.’ He says this is ‘an incredible milestone that highlights the enduring power of this brand and the limitless opportunities ahead.’ THE PROBLEM WITH SURVEYS… We have mentioned on a number of occasions that surveys often ‘prove’ what the person paying for them wants to see. Herewith a piece that we sent out to clients last week… • …and the above is either a) remarkable that the financial sponsor is always correct in his / her assumptions or b) indicative that ‘adverse’ surveys never see the light of day or c) it suggests that some bias may be at work.It may be all three, of course. But here we just consider the last of the above. • The sample may have a built in bias: Acknowledgements here to Darrell Huff’s 1954 book, How to Lie with Statistics. Getting back to the subtitle, this may be on purpose or by accident. If you survey people with the question ‘do you like to respond to surveys’, you are likely to get a more positive response than you perhaps deserve. Less obviously, if you knock on doors to ask questions at 3pm you won’t access the same people that you would if you knocked at 6pm. An it may be unconscious. Surveyors may be more comfortable asking questions of a certain ‘type’ of person. This may still come through if there is a strict gender, age and racial quota imposed. • The average may not be a representative ‘average’. The mean works when there is little deviation, for example, with regard to height. For wealth, on the other hand, it is less good. The average wealth, even for a place like West Palm Beach, would move sharply up or down were Elon Musk to move in or out. Many surveys do not detail their methodology. • The sample size may be too small. This is a precise of our Day in the Life from earlier in September, which illustrates the point. We have an oak tree that produces acorns. Half fall on the grass, where they are gently trodden into the mud and the other half land on the patio, where they are squashed and destroyed. A small sample weighted towards the mud-borne acorns would conclude that humans were the best thing that had happened to oak trees whilst the squashed patio nuts would conclude the opposite. A turkey, for example, is fed and coddled for every day except one. If you sampled its life randomly, you may get the wrong impression. • Conclusion: A widely-sourced survey of 2,000 or more (in the UK) should be representative if crafted carefully. But even that is not certain. We may need more detail but, as that would come ‘below the fold’, it may either never be published or, if it is, never read. HOLIDAYS & LEISURE TRAVEL: The TTG reports that TUI and easyJet holidays have both increased their ATOL carrying numbers for the coming year, while Jet2holidays ‘has frozen its allocation.’ Jet2 remains the UK’s single-largest ATOL holder with just over 7m passengers protected… • This is the first time that Jet2 has not expanded its carrying numbers, excluding the pandemic, since Thomas Cook failed in 2019. • EasyJet holidays has added 400,000 seats (17%) and TUI has raised its seat numbers by around 91,000 or just 1.5%. There were some 1,035 ATOL license holders due for renewal by the end of September and 934 operators renewed them. TTG says that there are a further 45 renewals either in progress or yet to meet the necessary licensing conditions. • The CAA says ‘the continued growth in Atol-protected holidays shows that travel remains a key priority for UK consumers.’ Some others may suggest that carriers are adding capacity at a time when demand may be set to soften. French air traffic controllers have suspended the strike that had been due to disrupt air travel across Europe this week. Luton Airport is reported to have posted a pre-tax profit of £89.8m for its latest financial year, up from £39.9m in the prior year. OTHER LEISURE: Stella David, CEO of Entain, which owns Ladbrokes and Coral, has called on the chancellor not to raise betting taxes in her upcoming budget. She says that higher taxes would force the company ‘to consider its investment level in the UK…’ • Ms David says ‘at the end of the day we want to make a profitable global business.’ She says ‘there are other markets we have to pivot to as being more worthy of investment. There will be consequences. Having a dislocating increase in tax will have a dislocating impact on the industry.’ Hat Trick Productions, which produces programmes such as Have I Got News For You and Mastermind, has reported a profit of around £857k in FY24, up from a pre-tax loss of £377k in the prior year. Audioboom has confirmed earlier Sky News reports that it ‘has appointed J Goodwin & Co LLP to manage a strategic review process which involves the consideration of, amongst other strategic options, the potential sale of the Company….’ • Audioboom goes on to say that ‘it has not received any proposal for the sale of the Company and, in particular, has not received an approach within the meaning of the City Code on Takeovers and Mergers.’ It adds that it ‘further confirms that it is in discussions with certain strategic partners and trade peers regarding potential commercial or strategic partnerships as part of the Strategic Review.’ The company says shareholders are urged to take no action at this time and that ‘further announcements will be made in respect of the Strategic Review as and when appropriate.’ FINANCE & MARKETS: The Office for Budget Responsibility on Friday produced its estimates for the UK economy in which it downgraded estimates on productivity and factored in higher debt payments. Sterling up slightly at $1.3445 and €1.1476. Oil higher at $65.38. UK 10 year gilt yield unchanged at 4.70%. World markets mostly better on Friday and into today and London set to open around 7 points better as at 6.30am. RETAIL WITH NICK BUBB: Nick is taking a short break. |
|



