Langton Capital – 2020-08-14 – Book review, EOTHO, London, NewRiver, quarantine plans & other:
Book review, EOTHO, London, NewRiver, quarantine plans & other:
A DAY IN THE LIFE:
The fact that Sadiq Khan is now imploring would be Central-Londoners to get back to the Capital and spend money, has brought home again that Langton is pretty typical of the wider economy as a whole – and of the people in it.
During lockdown we came home, we didn’t go out much, we cut our credit card spending by around half, we doubled the proportion within that spent on food, we didn’t spend on travel, we undertook fewer but larger shops, we cut costs at work and all the rest.
And, as lockdown has eased, we’ve put the second car back on the road, we’ve , we plumped for staycations, we’ve cautiously been out to pubs and restaurants but, much to Mr Khan’s annoyance, we’re still working from home and haven’t been to London since March.
Though, as home is 200 miles from EC2M and public transport volumes aren’t what they were, we have a decent excuse. But this is pretty big stuff for Central London operators such as Pret and the blizzard of grab n go restaurants, dependent largely on a 2hr (if they’re lucky) window of trade for only five days of the week.
And many of them didn’t have much of a balance sheet to begin with meaning that this could be existential (with all of its implications for footfall, jobs, business rates for councils etc).
But elsewhere, we haven’t been using cash (we drew money out of an ATM for the first time in four months last week), we’ve got the hang of Zoom, we’ve given the summer 2020 fashions a miss and have taken the plunge with DIY haircuts and, in addition, I haven’t worn long trousers since it got above 15 degrees.
Which has both confused the dog and led to allegations that I look like a tall Krankie. So, I really must lost the cap. Anyway, much cooler and a bit blowy up North. Have a good weekend and let’s move on to the news. Follow us on Twitter at @brumbymark.
LANGTON PREMIUM EMAIL:
Corporate Offer: Premium email just £295 (plus VAT) for a single subscriber or £495 (plus VAT) for multiple subscribers. Drop us a line to get involved. Retail Offer: Easy in, easy out. £30 per month (inclusive of VAT, £25 net) via PayPal.
ADVERTISE WITH US:
Langton’s free email now carries adverts. See front page of website for today’s copy & contact us for further details.
BOOK REVIEW: FACTFULNESS – HANS ROSLING (2018 – posthumously published). Swedish doctor, academic & TED Talk favourite Hans Rosling, who sadly died in 2017, comments here on misconceptions regarding economics, politics & poverty. 14 Aug 2020:
• Rosling, who famously maintained that slow change is not the same as no change, said that attitudes, unless you work against your base instincts, can often be hard-wired in childhood / when your parents are or were young. See Premium Email.
PUB & RESTAURANT NEWS:
Covid news, trading etc.:
• CGA has reported on the government’s Eat Out to Help Out scheme saying that food sales rose by 31% on the first week of the offer as a whole across UK managed pubs and restaurants contacted.
• CGA says Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday of the first week of the offer saw food sales up by 100%, 95% and 106% respectively. These numbers will not include drink sales. Anecdotal evidence gathered by Langton suggests that week two was busier than week one.
• CGA confirms our earlier belief that cannibalisation was relatively slight with Thursday sales down by only 4% (in week one). The weekend crowd will be different to those dining on M, T & W, who many have decided to forego Thursday. Even during the Covid-19 pandemic, Fridays, Saturdays and Sunday lunchtimes (particularly in the good weather) remain a draw.
• CGA says that 27% of UK adults had used the scheme by this Tuesday (with 5 of the 13 days on which it will be offered gone). CGA says ‘the scheme appears to have achieved the sector’s hope of bringing back people who were previously hesitant about eating out. Two in five (39%) of those who have used Eat Out to Help Out were making their first visit to the sector since the end of lockdown. Of those who are still to eat or drink out, a quarter (26%) say they are likely to make use of the scheme before it ends.’
• We consider an extension is possible. This extension could (and maybe should) be viewed as a move to persuade the grey market to get involved as there is still some evidence of reticence here and many visitors at the moment will be families with school-age children.
• The scheme could be helping to build confidence. Any extension, which could be funded by some operators themselves if the Chancellor baulks at the cost, would put further clear water between operators that have reopened in an attempt to attract customers and those that have been slow to do so. See earlier Premium Emails for comments on margin, discounting and how some operators may struggle if others do press the ‘discount’ button/
• CGA says ‘along with operators’ stringent hygiene precautions, it is encouraging consumers to venture out and see that they can have a safe as well as good value meal out. As the scheme goes on it will hopefully begin to have a positive impact on footfall on other days of the week too—though it is already clear that the sector will need sustained support from government after the scheme ends at the end of the month.’ There is something of a cliff out there at present as EOTHO, the furlough scheme, 5% VAT and zero business rates (and the summer weather) will all finish at some point in the coming months.
• London mayor Sadiq Khan has said that people working from home has become a big problem for London. He had previously, in line with guidance, urged people to stay off the underground and to stay at home as much as possible. Now, this is becoming a bit of an issue.
• Mr Khan now says ‘the key thing I think we need to understand is that if we all stay at home working it’s a big problem for central London.’ He says ‘many small businesses rely on your workers going to work, the café bars, the dry cleaners, the shoe repair shops and others.’ Transport for London is running Tube and bus services at 15 per cent and 12 per cent respectively of their normal levels.
• Khan is calling for an extension to the present business rates holiday. London’s West End could lose £5bn in retail sales this year. This is currently due to end in March.
• The BBPA has welcomed the news that the US will not impose tariffs on UK beer. It says the market is worth £107 million to British brewers. The move (or absence of a move) ‘will aid British beer’s recovery from COVID-19.’
• CEO Emma McClarkin says ‘due to the fallout they are facing from the COVID-19 lockdown and the impact it has had on domestic sales of beer, exports like those to the US will be crucial for Britain’s brewers as they start to recover their trade.’ She continues ‘this is a positive signal of intent from the US for a good future trading relationship with UK brewers, enabling further growth for them in the US market.’
• Meanwhile spirts companies have been less than happy with the news that the US has said that it will maintain the tariff increase of 25% on over 100 European products including wine and spirits that it introduced last October.
• The Scotch Whisky Association says the tariffs are inflicting “huge damage” on the Scotch whisky sector. Exports to the US have fallen c30% since the tariffs were imposed. The Scotch Whisky industry is reported to support some 11,000 jobs.
• Commercial property and pub owning REIT NewRiver has updated on trading today saying that ‘the Company’s trading performance in the first quarter ended 30 June 2020 was in-line with our revised expectations as outlined in our Full Year Results on 18 June 2020.’
• NewRiver says 80% of Q2 rent has been collected (or alternative arrangements have been made). The group has stepped up its disposal efforts and says it has ‘£87 million of cash reserves and £45 million of undrawn revolving credit facilities, providing sufficient liquidity of £132 million.’
• NewRiver says ‘since the easing of lockdown, footfall has continued to improve across our retail portfolio’ and adds that, at Hawthorn Leisure, its pub-owning business, ‘over 90% of our community pubs in England, Scotland and Wales are now open and trading, following the easing of restrictions from 4 July 2020.’
• NewRiver says ‘the underlying performance of the pub estate has been solid, with like-for-like volumes down only 15% in our Leased & Tenanted estate and like-for-like sales down only 13% in our Operator Managed portfolio since 4 July 2020, compared to the same period last year.’
• The REIT says its pubs are ‘benefiting from: The community and suburban locations of our pubs…the wet-led nature of our portfolio and the lower fixed costs associated with running a wet-led business [and] ‘the fact that 86% of our pubs were invested in during lockdown, with our partners and tenants using Government support and their own capital to improve the standards of the pub with a particular focus on outdoor space investments, customer safety and customer hospitality.’
• The company adds that ‘over 70% of our pubs having outdoor space, with many of these performing in line with pre-COVID-19 levels’ also helps in the return to more normal trading. Since 1 April, the group has sold 13 pubs, generating £3.9 million in proceeds. See Nick Bubb below.
• Adnams yesterday reported H1 numbers to end-June saying that revenue was down by 40% at £20.95m and the group made a loss before tax of £3.9m (2019: loss £1.2m). Chairman Jonathan Adnams says of the Covid-19 pandemic ‘the hospitality sector was one of the hardest hit as socialising became heavily restricted and pubs were required to close their doors. As a pub owner and pub operator ourselves, and with a drinks business heavily orientated towards the on-trade, our business was focussed on our online sales, to our supermarket partners and other shops. These sales represented only about one fifth of our normal trade.’
• The company has benefited from the various government schemes but, in light of losses, no final dividend was paid for 2019 and no interim dividend is proposed for 2020. Adnams says ‘the Directors will keep the dividend policy under continuous review and return to paying dividends as soon as is appropriate.’
• Pre the lockdown, beer sales were running down 3% year on year. Clearly everything changed thereafter. The company mentions cost pressures but says ‘controlling costs, maximising opportunities, and delivering operational excellence at pace has ensured that we have continued to grow the parts of the business that could operate.’ Mr Adnams concludes ‘as we approach the Adnams’ 150th anniversary in 2022 we can look forward to building back better.’
• Devon and Dorset seafood restaurant operator Rockfish has reported that it has now reopened its entire estate of 9 units. It says ‘sales in some sites are already equal to last year and overall like for like (LFL) sales are currently only 7% below last summer’s trading despite social distancing measures which reduces covers available.’
• The Stay Original Company, which owns a collection of properties in the south of England, reports that its King’s Arms unit in Dorchester will open its doors and welcome guests on Thursday 17th September. The opening will be the fifth and largest property for the South West boutique hotel and pub group.
• Moet & Chandon has combined with Airship to offer customers buying a bottle of champagne from The Bottle Club will receive an e-voucher for two complimentary glasses of Moët & Chandon to toast with friends at any of The Alchemist group’s 20 bars across the country.
• New Look has launched a CVA. It says it will also launch a debt for equity swap.
HOLIDAYS & LEISURE TRAVEL:
• Travel plans have been further disrupted after the government included France, Malta and the Netherlands to the UK’s quarantine list. Travellers returning from those countries must self-isolate for 14 days on arrival in the UK. France has said it will introduce similar measures for visitors to the UK returning to France.
• Costa Cruises, which is owned by Carnival Corporation, has said that the restart of its cruises in September will be exclusively for Italian guests. Costa says ‘the decision was made considering the evolution of the epidemiological scenario and taking in account the regulation issued today by the Italian Ministry of Health regarding mandatory checks for travellers returning from some European and foreign destinations, which suggests a cautious approach.’
• STR reports that the US hotel industry saw occupancy down 33% in the week to 8 August with room rates down 25%. REVPAR was off by 49%.
• Uber rival Lyft has reported Q3 numbers saying that it generated revenue down 61% at $339m in the quarter with a loss of 141c per share.
• PM Boris Johnson has said the government will ease regulation regarding bowling alleys, casinos, skating rinks and beauty salons.
FINANCE & ECONOMICS:
• Cinema chain Vue is report by Sky to be close to securing a £100m debt package.
• Video game Fortnite owner Epic Games is to sue Apple and Google after the firms dropped the game from their app stores.
• Sterling little changed at $1.306 and €1.1053. Oil down a little at $45.11. UK 10yr gilt yield up 1bp at 0.25%. World markets lower yesterday. London set to open little changed.
START THE DAY WITH A SONG:
The song has been furloughed. See you on the other side.
RETAIL WITH NICK BUBB:
• Today’s News: Ahead of its AGM today, the community shopping centre and pub landlord NewRiver has issued a Q1 trading update, and there has also been news from QUIZ and Naked Wines: the new CEO of the high-flying Naked Wines, Nick Devlin, has had the confidence to pick up some more shares PA (c4300 at 456p) , whilst the embattled fashion chain QUIZ has announced an extension to its short-term overdraft facilities with HSBC, without saying why this might be needed. As for NewRiver they still make a virtue of the fact that “We continue to have limited exposure to the structurally challenged retail sub-sectors that have been particularly impacted by COVID-19, with no department stores in our portfolio, minimal exposure to mid-market fashion, and no exposure to (the most troubled) casual dining operators” and the operational metrics seem to bear them out, with 60% of rents in the last
• BDO High Street Sales Tracker: The BDO High Street Sales Tracker today for medium-sized Non-Food chains flags that in w/e Sunday Aug 9th, BDO Fashion LFL sales were down by c8% (with Store Fashion sales down c40% and Online Fashion sales up c57%), whilst Total BDO LFL sales (including a handful of Homewares and Lifestyle retailers, as well as Fashion retailers) were down by c7% (down c33% in Store sales, but up c73% in Online sales). However, it is worth bearing in mind that the index is constructed from an unweighted adjusted average of percentage changes and the sample base is not huge, so it needs to be taken with a pinch of salt. BDO note that, according to Springboard, footfall continues to be way down on last year (down 40% in the High Street and down 34% overall).
• News Flow Next Week: As we move even further on into the “dog days” of August, there is a fair bit going on next week, kicking off on Tuesday morning with the latest monthly Kantar/Nielsen grocery sales figures, followed at lunchtime that day with the Asda/Walmart Q2 results. The much-delayed final results from the hapless Frasers Group (aka Sports Direct) then come out on Thursday, along with the AO.com AGM. First thing on Friday we then get the widely followed GFK Consumer Confidence index for August, as well as the ONS Retail Sales figures for July…
TRADING STATEMENTS & EVENTS:
Upcoming results are set out below:
• 20 Aug 20 Tasty AGM
• 2 Sept 20 Gym Group H1 numbers
• 8 Sept 20 Fever Tree H1 numbers
• 8 Sept 20 DP Eurasia H1 numbers
• 10 Sept 20 Morrison’s H1 numbers
• 10 Sept 20 Rank FY numbers
• 30 Sept 20 Compass Group FY update
• 30 Sept 20 Everyman Media H1 numbers
• 6 Oct 20 Restaurant Group H1 numbers
• 9 Oct 20 JD Wetherspoon FY numbers
• 3 Nov 20 DART Group AGM
• 24 Nov 20 Compass Group FY numbers
• 26 Nov 20 Britvic FY numbers
Many results are likely to be delayed. For information purposes, the results below were delivered at these dates last year.
2019 COMPARATIVE RESULTS:
15 Aug 19 Vianet trading update, 22 Aug 19 Playtech H1, 22 Aug 19 Sportech H1, 28 Aug 19 Loungers FY results, 28 Aug 19 Fulham Shore AGM, 30 Aug 19 Gear 4 Music AGM, 6 Sep 19 Greene King AGM, 10 Sep 19 888 Holdings H1, 12 Sep 19 Comptoir H1, 19 Sep 19 Diageo AGM, 19 Sep 19 City Pub Group H1, 19 Sep 19 Saga H1, 23 Sep 19 Brighton Pier Group FY, 24 Sep 19 TUI Group FY trading update, 24 Sep 19 DP Poland H1, 24 Sep 19 Ten Entertainment H1, 24 Sep 19 Hotel Chocolat FY, 24 Sep 19 AG Barr trading update, 24 Sep 19 Tasty H1, 25 Sep 19 Shepherd Neame FY, 26 Sep 19 Time Out H1, 26 Sep 19 M&B FY trading update, 26 Sep 19 SSP FY update. 27 Sep 19 Escape Hunt H1
• Coffer Peach Tracker has LfLs down by 50.4% to just under half what they were a year ago in July. Wet sales down 41% in pubs. Restaurants down around 60% and Bars down 63%. Nightclubs & some other music venues not reopened yet.
• Reopening. This is gradual. Some units are good, pubs are better than restaurants & wet sales in pubs are ahead of food. All this data pre the EOTHO, which will have skewed things, perhaps only temporarily, the other way.
• Coffer Peach says, at end-July, only 36% of group-owned restaurants had reopened. EOTHO will have accelerated this a little in August. But talk of a fifth to a quarter never reopening may not be too wide of the mark.
• With EOTHO ending this month, furlough finishing shortly after & hospitality VAT rising from 5% to 20% in January, Alix Partners says there are concerns ‘that conditions will become more challenging during autumn and as winter draws in.’ You reckon?
LANGTON CAPITAL: Made in Hull. Like all the best things. Langton Capital is a financial advisory company providing insightful views on the UK and global leisure industry and the wider consumer sector in general. Subscription to the daily email is free. Unsubscribing is painless. We provide daily off the shelf and bespoke research. We have helped with transactions, fund-raisings, disposals and other corporate issues. We have a good ear, we are impartial, independent and not half bad at what we do. If you think that we could help you or your business, drop us a line.